Suffolk County Real Estate Search

Suffolk County Historical Properties for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Suffolk County and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Suffolk County real estate market? Sign up for a  Suffolk County Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Suffolk County Historical Properties for Sale

$1,900,000
4 Beds 5 Baths 3535437 MLS
Welcome to luxury living in this meticulously renovated 4200 sq.ft. Historic Colonial masterpiece brimming with unparrelled detail and character. Situated on an almost full acre of completely level land, this historic gem offers a rare opportunity to own a home that seamlessly blends modern convenience and looks with classic architecture and charm. From the grandeur of its sweeping facade to the open, spacious rooms within, this home is the showplace you have been waiting for. This outstanding home offers unmatched comfort, and style. No detail has been overlooked from the sleek finishes to the open concept layout, every inch of this home exudes sophistication. Whether you're relaxing by one of the 6 cozy fireplaces or entertaining guests in the spacious living areas, this property promises to exceed your every expectation. Don't miss the opportunity to make this exquisite residence your home for generations to come. As you step inside through the grand, 8 foot tall doorway into the open and welcoming foyer, you're greeted by the warmth of 6 inviting fireplaces scattered throughout the home, creating both cozy nooks for relaxation and glorious gathering spaces for lush entertaining. The expansive first floor features a guest bathroom, a sitting room/study adorned with beautiful French doors and fireplace, a large private office, and an open concept living room with fireplace and coffered ceiling,formal dining room with fireplace and gourmet kitchen outfitted with State of the Art appliances, and ample counter space all ideal and designed for entertaining guests of any number or just enjoying quiet family time. The .93 acre property offers you a serene oasis featuring 4 patios, a 3 car detached garage, parking for over 12 cars and a beautiful lush yard with more than enough room to build an Inground pool backyard paradise. The full, large unfinished basement with high ceilings is ready and waiting to be finished into even more luxury living space with enough room for a gym, wine cellar with tasting room, playroom, or even a movie theatre. Upstairs, retreat to the expansive bedrooms, each offering tranquility and privacy each with their own fireplaces and en suite baths. The primary suite features a private outdoor balcony, perfect for unwinding after a long day, a large walk in closet, and full en suite bathroom. Additionally upstairs, there is a full laundry room, and 2 large secondary bedrooms also featuring their own fireplaces and en suite baths. Each appointed with modern amenities and elegant finishes. The finished third floor bonus rooms include a full bathroom, playroom or sitting room and two additional bedrooms. A perfect hideout for young children, or a great place for guests to spend the night. This home exemplifies refined living at its finest, offering a perfect blend of sophistication, comfort, and elegance. The owner/builder is open and willing to make additions or changes at the buyers request and there is still time to choose the flooring for the first floor to suit your preferences. This is the home you've been looking for!

19 Thompson Hill Road, Saint James

$749,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 3535327 MLS
Welcome to the historic Cockroft Barn, a converted 1890s carriage house once owned by the infamous 1920s NYC mayor James Walker. Originally part of the esteemed St. Timothy's Farm estate, this remarkable property has evolved over a century, nestled in the charming village of Northport. Stepping into this unique residence, you are greeted by a grand 30-foot entry foyer adorned with the original peak rafters of the carriage house, complete with hay bale pulls-a testament to its rich history and unparalleled character. Boasting 4 bedrooms and a versatile 3rd-floor office/5th bedroom, along with 2 and a half bathrooms, the Cockroft Barn seamlessly blends old-world charm with modern amenities. The primary suite resides on the first floor, complemented by a spacious dining room, even larger formal living room, and a massive eat-in kitchen. Convenience is key with laundry facilities on the first floor and an additional half bath. Ascend to the second story loft, now transformed into a sprawling family room featuring a majestic 20-foot peaked ceiling and a cozy fireplace-an ideal space for gatherings and relaxation. Two more bedrooms and a full bath complete the second level, while a bonus room awaits on the third floor, perfect for an office or additional sleeping quarters. The property, just shy of an acre, offers a flat expanse of land beckoning for outdoor enjoyment and family activities. Situated mere minutes from Main Street Northport, residents can indulge in shopping, dining, and the vibrant atmosphere of the village. As a cherry on top, ownership of the Cockroft Barn grants access to the exclusive Willo Beach Association. Experience the timeless allure and storied legacy of the Cockroft Barn-an extraordinary blend of heritage, elegance, and modern comfort, ready to welcome you home. MORE PICS COMING

30 Nautilus Avenue, Northport

$819,990
3 Beds 2 Baths 3535008 MLS
Additional photos to come! This stunning Colonial home, nestled in the prestigious south of Montauk Hwy location in Islip, exudes timeless Old World Charm while boasting modern updates that enhance its beauty. Originally built in 1900, this residence offers a blend of historic elegance and contemporary comforts. The focal point of the home is the renovated Eat-in Kitchen, which showcases radiant floors, exquisite granite countertops, built-in features, and updated appliances, including two stainless steel wall ovens, catering to both culinary enthusiasts and those who appreciate a stylish space for entertaining. The addition of a new bathroom and laundry area adds convenience and functionality to everyday living. The first floor encompasses spacious living areas, including a large formal dining room, a cozy den, and a living room adorned with a fireplace, providing the perfect ambiance for gatherings and relaxation. Ascending to the second floor, you'll find a luxurious master suite complete with a balcony, offering a private retreat to unwind and enjoy the views. Two additional generously sized bedrooms and an updated bathroom with radiant heat flooring further enhance the comfort and charm of this home, creating an inviting atmosphere that truly makes you feel at home. With its combination of classic architectural features and modern amenities, this Colonial residence embodies the essence of gracious living and promises a lifestyle of comfort and elegance in one of Islip's most desirable neighborhoods. There is a two car detached garage with professionally landscaped yard with custom masonry work and fenced in backyard offering privacy and charm.

65 Willow Avenue, Islip

$16,500,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 3534922 MLS
"The Point", A Bellport Village Estate. A rendezvous with Fabled Grandeur Embrace the rare opportunity and make "The Point" a place where your story unfolds. This exclusive and secluded retreat welcomes you in, via private road and along the graceful winding stone driveway, leading to a sprawling one-story home. Enter its threshold and experience the sense of timeless elegance, nestled in Long Island's storied enclave of Bellport Village. This 5-bed, 5-bath waterfront home, rests upon 3.37 acres of verdant beauty, baring the signature of a bygone era and the utmost luxury of today's living standards. Inside, feel the embrace and warmth of the expansive living room, adorned with high vaulted ceilings, original beams and mahogany paneled archways. The space features a generous fireplace, ample seating options and bird's eye views of the Great South Bay, perfect for hosting cherished guests. Beyond, along the South elevation, is a stunning and generous sunroom opening out upon manicured gardens, patio with pool and spa, all overlooking the expansive lawn stretching out to sandy beach and water. Bathed in the natural light streaming through near-floor-to-ceiling windows and skylight, the comfortable space stays cozy on winter days with radiant floor heating banishing any chill. Adjacent to both the living room and sunroom, a TV room awaits, complete with built-in bookcases, and beyond that, a gym for those seeking an active experience. Gracious hallways lead to numerous comfortable en-suite bedrooms, all serene retreats. The generous primary bedroom offers water views, walk in closet, and stunning en-suite bath. Indulge in luxury with radiant heat stone flooring, over-sized soaker tub and spacious shower, all with a captivating view of the water. As you meander East through the home you'll find the stunning dining room with built in window seating running along its length, a fully-equipped eat in kitchen, and cozy breakfast nook boasting breathtaking water and sky views. Beyond, discover additional bedrooms, bathrooms and laundry-mudroom, ensuring effortless living. Work from home, in the large office complete with mesmerizing water vistas. "The Point" offers an unparalleled lifestyle. Explore the grounds and discover the har-tru tennis court, inviting you to play a friendly match. Along the shoreline, you will find yourself surrounded by lush lawn, sandy beach and magnificent Gunite pool enclosed by hedge and white picket gates. Throughout the property, exquisite sculptures add thoughtful and artistic touches. As you head north along the point, you'll encounter a deep-water dock, additional outbuildings, perfect for boating and water sports enthusiasts. Exit the property past additional garages with room to house 7 vehicles. Bask in privacy and tranquility offered by endless lush landscaping and impeccable bouldered sea wall. Enjoy the charm of 1920s architecture, and take advantage of the nearby country club, summer concerts, private ocean beach and a thriving arts scene. Just 53 miles East of NYC and 20 miles West of the Hamptons, discover your legacy waiting to be continued. Reach out to secure your personal viewing and delve into the estate's architectural and historical detail. Own your piece of Long Island's fabled past and distinctive present. Let your story continue here. An exclusive offering tailored for those who value the confluence of history, luxury and exclusivity.

16 Point Road, Bellport Village

$12,900,000
13 Beds 13 Baths 3534781 MLS
This majestic, one-of-a-kind estate is set on 4+ private, resort-like acres south of Montauk Highway. Its unique location on the southwest-facing waterfront provides incredible sunset views over Seatuck Cove and Moriches Bay from large windows throughout the bright, airy main residence. Perfect for entertaining, the meticulously updated 9-bedroom, 9.5-bath main home features a chef's kitchen with granite countertops, Wolf stove, dual ovens and dishwashers, and a 17-foot island. There's a living room with a built-in bar and wood-burning fireplace, a dining room, family room, handsome library and sunroom with wood-burning fireplaces, and a temperature-controlled wine cellar; and French doors lead to an ample patio overlooking the water. The primary bedroom has dual closets, custom built-ins, a bathroom with radiant floor and dual vanities, and a porch with sweeping water views. A former 19th century hunting lodge, the home blends old world charm with modern-day amenities, including an elevator and state-of-the-art mechanical systems, and features a porte cochere for shelter when getting in and out of vehicles. The sprawling property, which is bordered by tall perimeter trees and accessed through a gated entrance, includes a four-bedroom guest house with full kitchen; a detached five-car garage with commercial-grade hydraulic car lifts; a charming, refurbished, old-fashioned windmill; and a pool house with sauna, and gym overlooking the 45x20 heated saltwater gunite pool. A sweeping, lush lawn extends down to 234 feet of waterfront, where there are docks, a sandy beach and a boathouse. Har-tru tennis courts complete the country club experience. There's little reason to ever leave!

74 Cedar Lane W, Remsenburg

$1,200,000
6 Beds 5 Baths 3534682 MLS
Nestled within the charming neighborhood of Bayport, this exquisite 6-bedroom Colonial unfolds a history of luxury. Greeted by a captivating Great Room that commands attention to the soaring 32-foot ceilings, inviting natural sunlight to dance across handcrafted wood floors. The master kitchen boasts stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and an oversized island that is a focal point for culinary creativity. The Master- suite on the first floor has walk in closets and private bath. Main floor laundry and central vacuum system ensure daily tasks are seamlessly integrated into daily life. A additional summer kitchen is equipped with Beko Professional Stove, walk in panrty perfect for easy outside entertaining. Built in cabinetry adorned with leaded glass. The upper floor features two staircases leading to five bedrooms. One wing of the house has two bedrooms and an office/gym separated by a breezeway connecting to another wing which has three bedrooms. This design provides seperation between each wing while maintaining a connection between the upper floor. Picturesque outdoor oasis features semi-inground pool enveloped by 1,200 sq. feet of decking.Tiki bar with running water , and a wine fridge creature a idyllic setting for leisurely moments. Three car garage is equipped with heating and air conditioning, an additional one-car garage provides extra storage or a workshop. Bayport BluePoint Blue Ribbon Schools, Enjoy the South Shore playground to Fire Island and beautiful beaches, take a look and bring the entire family.

466 Gillette Avenue, Bayport

$850,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 3534518 MLS
Gracious Great South Bay living awaits you in this charming colonial located south of Montauk Highway in Brightwaters. This meticulously maintained residence boasts tons of curb appeal, comfort and convenience. Step inside the inviting entry foyer and discover generously appointed living spaces within. The large formal living room exudes sophisticated elegance and is adorned with a cozy fireplace, ideal for gatherings or quiet evenings by the fire. Adjoined by a spacious den, retreat to this sun- filled sanctuary with tile flooring that offers contemporary sophistication. Entertain with style in the large formal dining room, featuring wainscot molding and French doors that open onto the deck, offering seamless indoor-outdoor flow. The eat in kitchen is a chef's delight, boasting granite countertops and stainless steel appliances. Enjoy meals seated by the charming bay window overlooking the lush yard or with the well-placed door to the deck, step outside for alfresco dining. Completing the main level is a convenient half bath/powder room and staircase with landing that enhances the flow between the kitchen and living room. The second floor offers a light filled primary bedroom with large closet and three additional well-sized bedrooms, all offering comfort and privacy. A bright and spacious full bath with tub and shower serves the second floor, while a pull-down staircase provides access to the spacious attic for additional storage. The finished basement offers versatile living space, including a family room area, a laundry room, and ample storage and with an outside entrance, providing added convenience and functionality. Moving to the exterior offerings of this home, you will find a large two-car detached garage with an oversized bonus room above, perfect for an office or additional recreation space. The generously proportioned driveway is lined with Belgian Block and provides more than ample parking. Outdoor convenience can be found at the outdoor shower that certainly comes in handy on beach days! The entertainers yard boasts a spacious deck and serene Koi pond making your Bayway backyard the perfect place for relaxation and gatherings. Gorgeous hardwood flooring and crown moldings throughout are just some of the stunning features of this home. Along with modern conveniences and efficiencies such as central air, gas heat and solar panels, not to mention the invigorating natural breezes from the Great South Bay, form and function make this Bayway beauty with an ideal layout the oasis you've been looking for! Enjoy village amenities such as docking, beach, parks, tennis and more. Make this meticulous colonial by the bay , your South Shore of Long Island sanctuary!

156 Bayway Avenue, Brightwaters

Start Your Search

Information Copyright 2024, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.