Garden City Real Estate Search

Garden City Historical Properties for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Garden City and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Garden City real estate market? Sign up for a  Garden City Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Garden City Historical Properties for Sale

$3,188,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 3504689 MLS
Central section 6 bedroom brick colonial, first floor spacious foyer, step down LR with contemporary new FP, Large bdrm, formal DR, Stunning Kitchen / great room with FP, Sky Lights, high end appliances, walk in pantry, coffee bar and large eating area. Enormous bonus room off kitchen, Private primary suite, new bathroom with separate shower, double sinks and free standing soaker tub and very spacious closet. Another on suite bedroom/ bathroom, three additional bedrooms and hall bath, laundry complete this floor. unfinished large basement. CAC, IGS,Pella french doors, Anderson windows

92 3rd Street, Garden City
$715,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 3504438 MLS
House is AS IS. CASH BUYER/INVESTOR/BUILDER ONLY. It has been fully cleared out and ready for renovation. Kitchen completely raw space. Serious inquiries only. Call front desk for appt.

105 Meadow Street, Garden City
$849,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 3504358 MLS
A Graceful Colonial on Desirable Quiet Street in Garden City is Available for the First Time in almost 70 Years! Situated on a Large Private Lot patiently awaiting its next owner. Upon entering through a Front Vestibule, an Inviting LR with Wood Burning Fireplace adjoins a Breezy Screened Porch, as well as a Large Gracious Formal DR. 8.5' Ceilings and Beautiful Scissored Staircase with Turned Balusters and Detailed Moldings Throughout complete your First Glance. The EIK has a Side Entry via the Driveway with access to Powder Room and an unfinished cellar. The Second floor Offers Three bedrooms serviced by a Full Hall Bath w/ Tub and a Walk-in Shower. A Lovely Open Stairway Leads you to the Third floor w/ a Bedroom and Deep Soaking tub full bathroom, as well as Two Large Attic Spaces that lends itself to Amazing Ideas! Hardwood floors as seen throughout. Character & Fantastic Space in a Peaceful Location with Endless Possibilities, an Opportunity Not to be Missed! Home Sold "As Is".

143 Chestnut Street, Garden City
$1,375,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 3503617 MLS
Welcome to this exceptional Tudor-style home, where the leaded glass doorway welcomes you into a spacious foyer. The large sunken living room, featuring a carved stone fireplace with 'Irish Linen' woodwork paneling, becomes a great place to unwind. Entering the eat-in-kitchen, the cathedral ceiling creates an open and airy atmosphere. Rounding out the first floor, a full bath and cozy den/library, features access to a spacious patio, adding to the private lush yard. The winding staircase leads you to the second floor which boats three spacious, bright bedrooms, each with ample closet space and a full hall bath. Basement offers plenty of space to accommodate all your modern needs. A complete story book feel!

43 Brixton Road, Garden City
$1,739,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 3503369 MLS
Perfectly situated midblock center hall colonial in the heart of the desired Estates. Open concept living with full renovation from 2018. Gleaming hardwood floors, wood burning fireplace, center hall foyer, 8' kitchen island with quartz countertops, Bertazonni Stove, wine fridge, and many more amenities. 4 generously sized bedrooms on the second level with Hall Full bath, and Primary Suite with walk-in closet and double vanity en-suite bathroom with oversized shower. Full third floor walk up attic perfect for storage. Fully finished basement with bonus bedroom perfect for guest or au-pair. Additional basement full bath and laundry room. Manicured landscape with paver stone patio, electric dog fence, electrical vehicle charger, and House Generator connection for emergency power.

143 Kensington Road, Garden City
$950,000
7 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 3502120 MLS
Very large home with Great Potential.

102 Roosevelt Street, Garden City
$1,849,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 3499109 MLS
Sun-Filled Estates 6 bedroom,3.5. bath, center hall Newport Dutch Colonial sits on a corner lot with a driveway on Chester. Summer evenings on your front porch with French doors to foyer and family/dining room. Brand new windows throughout, new sprinklers, updated 200 amp electrical with electric vehicle garage charger and updated landscape. Enter through the front door and arrive at a wide, through, center hall with access to the LR with wood burning fireplace, gracious sized family room, and winding staircase--extending up all 3 floors. French doors off the Foyer entrance and family room make for ideal indoor/outdoor entertaining. Large, updated, Cook's kitchen with a second fireplace and new Thermador appliances. Large eat-in kitchen with a transitional dining room, half-bath, and back door mud-room area complete the first floor. Head upstairs and find a large hall with access to all 4 bedrooms on the same floor. There is a huge primary suite with updated en-suite bath, 3 nicely-sized BR's, and an updated shared bath. New second floor laundry. The open 3rd fl has 2 more BR's and full bath. Other: Basement rec room, 2 car garage and fenced-in yard.

18 Nassau Boulevard, Garden City
$1,699,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 3498533 MLS
Welcome to this exquisite Colonial masterpiece that seamlessly blends classic elegance with modern comforts. With 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms and 2 half baths, this home offers spacious living combined with luxurious amenities. As you step inside, you'll immediately notice the grandeur of the 9-foot ceilings throughout, adorned wit intricate crown moldings that add a touch of sophistication to every room. The attention to detail is evident as you explore this meticulously crafted residence. For those who love to entertain, the spacious formal dining room sets the stage for unforgettable gatherings. This room effortlessly leads into the kitchen, ensuring that both hosting and preparing meals are seamless and enjoyable experiences. The heart of this home is the updated eat-in kitchen, featuring top-of-the-line appliances complete with a Sub-zero refrigerator/freezer, double oven, Blomberg dishwasher, and Wolf range. The formal and elegant living room boasts a wood-burning fireplace with a decorative mantel, creating a cozy atmosphere for gatherings and quiet evenings alike. Flowing seamlessly from the living room, the den bathes in natural light and offers picturesque views of the inviting backyard. The primary bedroom ensuite, on the second floor, is a haven of comfort, complete with a gas fireplace that adds warmth and ambiance. The 3 other expansive bedrooms provide ample space for relaxation and personalization, ensuring everyone has their own oasis. A bonus space on the 3rd level presents endless possibilities - whether it's a home office, gym, or creative retreat. The versatility of this home truly sets it apart. Efficiency meets comfort with 5-zone gas heating and 2-zone CAC, ensuring your comfort in every season. Storage will never be an issue, thanks to the abundance of storage spaces throughout the property. The full finished walk-out basement also has an abundance of storage, a half bath, laundry room and versatility galore. The detached 1-car garage provides convenience and practicality. An updated powder room in the entryway and upgraded light switches throughout reflect the thoughtful updates make to enhance your living experience. Tall, mature box hedges offer additional privacy and contribute to the impeccable curb appeal of this home. The newer roof and in-ground sprinkler system are practical additions that enhance the overall value of the property. This Colonial gem with its spacious rooms, stunning finishes, and thoughtful amenities is more than just a great house; it's a place to call HOME! Conveniently located near 2 LIRR lines and shops, it doesn't get much better than this. Don't miss the opportunity to make this exceptional residence your very own.

106 Salisbury Avenue, Garden City
$1,455,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 3494148 MLS
Rare Find Famed Architect Olive Tjaden Designed Brick Side Hall Colonial Located in the Heart of the Desirable Estates Section Set on 80x100 Property w Mature Plantings Offering a Flexible Floor-plan w Room to Expand if Desired Many Original Details;Custom Moldings Oak Hardwood Floors Thru-out Custom Bow Window French Doors Enter to Foyer w Large Coat Closet Powder Room Updated EIK w to the Ceiling Cabinets Granite Counters & Stainless Steel Appliances Entertainment Sized Living Room w Wood Burning Fireplace Bow Window& Custom Mantle Banquet Size Formal Dining Rm, Roomy Family Rm,Home Office/Sitting Room Complete 1st Floor Upstairs King Size Primary w Updated En-suite Bath w Stall Shower 2nd Beyond King Size Bdrm w Dressing Room Sitting Area & Double Closet Queen Size Bedroom w 2 Closets Updated Hall Bath w Stall Shower & Separate Tub Lots of Storage & Full Attic w Pull-down Huge Finished Basement w High Ceilings Pergo Floors 2 Big Rooms w 4 Full Size Windows Great Extra Family and Office Space Laundry & Utility Room Oversized 2 Car Garage-Park 2 Sport Utility Vehicles & Still Have Storage,Double Width & Double Length Driveway Park 8-10 Cars, Fenced Backyard Paver Patio Koi Pond & Room to Play! 2 Blocks to GC Country Club 1/2 Block to Nassau Blvd Station Public School Bus Stop in Front of House Near to Playground Homestead Primary Stratford Grammar agent owner

81 Wellington Road, Garden City
$789,000
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 3491428 MLS
Rare Opportunity in Garden City School District! A Charming 4 Bedroom Cape On a Quiet Tree-Lined Street. Only 1/2 Block to LIRR Stewart Manor Station Platform Making This A Great Location for Commuters! New Roof, New Electric Service/Panel, New Boiler & Burner, Gas Cooking. New Belgian Block Porch, Walkway & Driveway. Detached 1.5 Car Garage. Don't Miss this Opportunity to Make this Home Your Own!

118 Jefferson Street, Garden City
$2,850,000
6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 3490204 MLS
OPULENCE ABOUNDS THROUGHOUT! No expense was spared in renovating this classic Olive Tjaden English Tudor 10 years ago. Like NO English Tudor you've ever seen. Each piece of stained glass has been restored. Huge Entry Foyer w/FP leads to COOK'S KITCHEN/GREAT ROOM/gas FP (MUST SEE "LA CORNUE 8-BURNER STOVE). Primary Bedroom w/ensuite WATERWORKS FULL bathroom PLUS 4 BR + 3 FULL BA, ALSO on 2nd FL. Walk-up stairway to 3rd Floor BR?BA + Storage. AMAZING TUSCAN Wine-Tasting Room/Wine Cellar + "Man Cave" Cigar Room w/air-filtration system on Lower Level plus Powder Room + HUGE FINISHED AREA to "make your own!" This home is BEYOND PRISTINE! Lovingly restored and maintained = "better than new.!!" WALLCOAT PAINT (never paint again!" Water-filtration system throughout. 4-zone Central Air + Gas/steam heat. Sound System + "Smart House" throughout. Newly-built Garage w/car lift holds 2 cars within - MORE ON DRIVEWAY. Lovely Patio with PRIVATE Side Yard - convenient to Kitchen. New Copper on Slate Roof. QUALITY + CRAFTSHMANSHIP IS IMPOSSIBLE TO REPLICATE -- IT'S BEEN DONE FOR YOU!! MODERN ELEGANCE PERSONIFIED!! MUST SEE!

102 Brixton Road, Garden City
$6,750,000
5 Beds ⋅ 10 Baths ⋅ 3430085 MLS
MAGNIFICENT, one-of-a kind property, situated mid block in the heart of the Central Section of Garden City. Enter into the expansive foyer with a winding 3-story staircase. First floor features FLR, FDR, home office, open kitchen, pantry, rear mud room & den. Bedrooms abound in this home; 5 total, 3 with attached sitting room. Primary BR offers a vast WIC and gorgeous full bath. 3 1/2 additional baths in the main house. Warm yourself by one of the 4 fireplaces. Full finished basement features a media and wine room. Travel through the newly constructed 60' UNDERGROUND PASSAGEWAY to the spectacular, newly built 4900+ sq. ft. auxiliary structure, boasting a 14'x24' heated indoor pool, fitness room, 2 full baths, 3 car garage & a 1305 sq. ft. terrace room perfect for entertaining family & friends! Four sets of French doors open to overlook the beautifully landscaped yard. Upper-level recreation room including powder room and gas fireplace. An abundance of amenities! Too many to list!

67 3rd Street, Garden City
$3,625,000
4 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 3478217 MLS
Pristine and magnificent Mediterranean Colonial home located on 125 x 250 mid-block in the central section of Garden City. Home has an abundant amount of living, entertainment and storage space and maintains many of its original architectural details but has been updated throughout for living today in luxury and comfort. First floor features a breathtaking entry foyer with 3-story open staircase, gracious living room with gas fireplace and floor to ceiling windows, an amazing formal dining room with gas fireplace with white oak paneling and beamed ceiling, a cheerful sun porch with wood burning fireplace and a powder room. The large granite eat-in kitchen is adjacent to a sunlit family room. Second floor features a home office, a primary bedroom with en suite full bath, a gas fireplace, a dressing room with built-in cabinets and walk-in closets. There is a guest room with an en suite full bath plus two additional bedrooms, a large one with wood burning fireplace, a hall full bath, a laundry, and a walk-in hall linen closet. The third floor features an open stairway to large multipurpose room to suit your personal needs. This floor also features significant storage areas, HVAC equipment and communication/security systems. The basement level has a full bath, a large pantry, another full laundry, mechanicals, as well as a billiard room and wine cellar/tasting room finished with brick walls and hand-crafted wood ceilings and millwork. This property has a huge professionally landscaped yard that provides a very private, tranquil retreat and is ready for a pool if desired. There is a 3-car garage and hobby center, with high ceilings (11+ ft.), large work areas that can be used for whatever one imagines, and a walk-up office with half-bath. This building was built to match the design of the house, and there is also a matching storage building. The roofs and copper work were recently redone, and each floor has a separate CAC system. Old world artisan craftsmanship is exhibited throughout the property while modern HVAC, communication, security, electrical and water systems support a healthy, safe and connected environment for today's living. TRULY, A ONE-OF-A-KIND MASTERPIECE!

105 Tenth Street, Garden City
$2,050,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 3410382 MLS
Magnificent 1920s Tudor with five bedrooms and office , four full bathrooms, and two half bathrooms is nestled on nearly an 1/2 acre of lushly landscaped property bordering the Golf Club. Offering 4,555 sq ft of living space that is ideal for entertaining and features exquisite trim and crown molding, hardwood floors, and distinctive architectural elements. An impressive open foyer with elegant wood paneling invites you inside to a spacious living room with an wood-burning fireplace. Two sets of French doors open to a sunroom with all-around views of the grounds. The banquet-sized formal dining room flows to a comfortable den or office. A gourmet kitchen with granite counters, high-end appliances including a Viking range, custom cabinetry and center island. First floor boasts wash room, butler's pantry and sun filled breakfast area. As if that isn't enough, this exceptional home includes a detached two-car garage w/ loft , covered patio and all with amazing views of the Golf Club.*Homeowners are presently grieving the taxes*

120 Cherry Valley Avenue, Garden City
Start Your Search

Information Copyright 2023, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.